Social Theories of Muslim Thinkers

Social Theories of Muslim Thinkers

A Comparative Study of the Causes of Progress and Decline in Societies: Revisiting the Thought of Muhammad Baqir al-Sadr and New Institutionalists

Document Type : Research Article / Original Article

Authors
Ali Saeedi 1
Mohammad Javad Masuminia 2
1 Assistant Professor of Islamic Economics, University of Qom, Qom, Iran.
2 PhD Student of Islamic Economics, University of Qom, Qom, Iran.
10.22059/jstmt.2026.401119.1852
Abstract
The inquiry into the fundamental drivers of societal progress and stagnation has long occupied a central position in social and economic thought. In contemporary literature, New Institutionalists such as Douglass North and Daron Acemoglu have sought to explain the divergent trajectories of societies by elucidating institutional mechanisms and demonstrating the correlation between the quality of political and economic institutions and developmental outcomes. Conversely, Muhammad Baqir al-Sadr advances a distinct framework of social transformation through a historical and analytical methodology centered on the pursuit of justice, public participation, and communal leadership. Employing an exploratory and comparative-analytical approach based on primary textual sources, this study critically examines these two paradigms. The findings reveal that al-Sadr, unlike New Institutionalists, conceptualizes institutions as inherently ideological and value-laden. He contends that institutional effectiveness and legitimacy cannot be objectively evaluated in isolation from a comprehensive ideological worldview and the fundamental criterion of justice. While New Institutionalism implicitly presupposes liberal capitalism as an indispensable prerequisite for development, al-Sadr posits that the normative evaluation of social systems based on justice must logically precede the appraisal of individual institutional arrangements. Furthermore, al-Sadr identifies the primary catalyst for societal transformation not merely in elite management, social pressures, or critical junctures, but fundamentally in inner human transformation and the ideological alignment of the community (Ummah). Within this framework, in contemporary Iran, the institution of Wilayat al-Faqih (Guardianship of the Jurist), the jurisprudence-based constitution, and the sociopolitical structure fostering public alignment with the Islamic system provide the institutional foundation for developmental progress. This structural alignment has enabled the country to overcome the historical cycle of dependency and underdevelopment, charting a distinct trajectory from secular models. Ultimately, al-Sadr’s justice-oriented theory presents a robust normative critique of secular functionalist institutionalism, offering a viable alternative developmental model for Islamic societies.
Keywords
Institutions
Justice
Muhammad Baqir al-Sadr
New Institutionalism
Societal Progress
Subjects
Acemoglu, D., & Johnson, S. (2023). Power and progress: Our thousand-year struggle over technology and prosperity. PublicAffairs.
Acemoglu, D., & Robinson, J. A. (2006). Economic origins of dictatorship and democracy. Cambridge University Press.
Acemoglu, D., & Robinson, J. A. (2012). Why nations fail: The origins of power, prosperity, and poverty. Crown Business.
Aghnazari, H. (2017). Methodology of Islamic economics with an institutional reality approach. Research Institute of Hawzah and University. [In Persian]
Esmaeili, M., & Tahanehzif, H. (2008). Analysis of the nature of the general policies institution in the constitutional law of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Public Law Journal, 9(28), 93–127. [In Persian]
Farzin, M. R., Moqsoodi, H. R., & Saedi, A. (2018). Economic system of the Islamic Republic of Iran’s model (Research Project). Supreme National Defense University. [In Persian]
Foley, D. K. (2013). Adam’s fallacy: A guide to economic theology (A. Saedi & H. R. Moqsoodi, Trans.). Imam Sadiq University Press. [In Persian]
Ghollami, A., & Bahadori Jahromi, A. (2013). Concept, nature, and oversight of the implementation of general policies. Public Law Studies, 2(1), 51–72. [In Persian]
Gholami, M. (2014). A comparative study of the impact of institutions on the economy from the perspective of institutional economics and Islamic economics with emphasis on the government institution [Master’s thesis, Faculty of Economic Sciences]. [In Persian]
Joshaqani Nayini, S. H., Tavakoli, M. J., & Davoodi, P. (2017). Conceptual evolution of institutions and its implications for institutional studies in Islamic economics and Iran’s economy. Iranian Economic Essays, 14(28), 97–120. [In Persian]
Karami, M. H., & Goodarzi, S. (2018). Implications of new institutionalism for Islamic economics in confronting external effects. Islamic Economic Knowledge, 10(19), 101–122. [In Persian]
Khadem Alizadeh, A., & Solymanzadeh Ayidish, R. (2018). A comparative study of the epistemology of Islamic economics and new institutional economics. Islamic Economics and Banking Journal, 7(22), 7–25. [In Persian]
Levent, A. (2022). Islamic economics and institutional economics: A methodological discussion. In T. S. Arouri & A. Levent (Eds.), Institutional Islamic economics and finance (pp. 10–26). Routledge.
North, D. C. (1981). Structure and change in economic history. W. W. Norton & Company.
North, D. C., Wallis, J. J., & Weingast, B. R. (2009). Violence and social orders: A conceptual framework for interpreting recorded human history. Cambridge University Press.
North, D. C., Webb, S. B., & Boghossian, A. A. (Eds.). (2012). In the shadow of violence: Politics, economics, and the problems of development. Cambridge University Press.
Rubin, J. (2024). Religion and new institutional economics. In C. Ménard & M. M. Shirley (Eds.), A research agenda for new institutional economics (pp. 953–974). Edward Elgar Publishing.
Saeedi, A. (2022). Introduction and critique of the book Methodology of Islamic Economics with an Institutional Reality Approach. Critical Studies on Texts and Programs of Human Sciences, 22(5), 59–82. [In Persian]
Sadr, M. B. (1993). Al-Bank al-la rabawi fi al-Islam. Dar al-Ta’aruf li al-Matbu’at. [In Arabic]
Sadr, M. B. (2000). Al-Islam yaqud al-hayat, risalatuna, maktab al-Islam. Dar al-Sadr. [In Arabic]
Sadr, M. B. (2014a). Our philosophy (S. A. Hosseini Zarfa, Trans.). Dar al-Sadr. [In Persian]
Sadr, M. B. (2014b). Our economics (Vols. 1–2; S. M. M. Borhani & S. A. Hosseini Zarfa, Trans.). Dar al-Sadr. [In Persian]
Sadr, M. B. (2014c). Islam guides life, our mission, and Islamic school of thought (M. Zandieh, Trans.). Dar al-Sadr. [In Persian]
Sadr, M. B. (2014d). Barqaha (S. O. Moazeni, Trans.). Dar al-Sadr. [In Persian]
Social Theories of Muslim Thinkers
Volume 16, Issue 2
Spring 2026
Pages 141-162

  • Receive Date 13 December 2025
  • Revise Date 19 April 2026
  • Accept Date 02 June 2026
  • Publish Date 22 June 2026